Quote comparison sheet
Put your own estimate and every tender into the same lines. Then normalise: add back anything a tenderer excluded, so you're comparing complete prices. The Excel version adds up the subtotals, VAT, totals and the difference from your estimate for you.
Download Excel (.xlsx) Download CSV
| Line | Your estimate (EUR ex VAT) | Builder A | Builder B | Builder C | Notes / exclusions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Preliminaries & PSCS (site set-up, welfare, scaffold, skips, insurances) | |||||
| 2 Demolition / strip-out | |||||
| 3 Substructure (foundations, pads, ground floor slab) | |||||
| 4 Frame & upper floors (incl. structural steel) | |||||
| 5 Roofs | |||||
| 6 External walls & cladding | |||||
| 7 Windows & external doors (install, beyond PC sum) | |||||
| 8 Internal walls, doors & joinery | |||||
| 9 Finishes (plaster, drylining, tiling, flooring fit) | |||||
| 10 Mechanical (heating, plumbing, ventilation) | |||||
| 11 Electrical | |||||
| 12 External works & drainage (incl. wastewater) | |||||
| 13 Attendance on PC items | |||||
| Measured works subtotal | sum of elements 1-13 | ||||
| PC: Windows, doors & screens | same allowance for every tenderer | ||||
| PC: Kitchen & utility | same allowance for every tenderer | ||||
| PC: Solar PV | same allowance for every tenderer | ||||
| PC: Sanitary ware | same allowance for every tenderer | ||||
| PC: Stairs | same allowance for every tenderer | ||||
| PC: Flooring / tiling / carpets | same allowance for every tenderer | ||||
| PC: Light fittings | same allowance for every tenderer | ||||
| PC: Other (list) | same allowance for every tenderer | ||||
| PC sums subtotal | |||||
| Overheads & profit (OH&P) | % or lump sum | ||||
| Subtotal ex VAT | |||||
| VAT (check rate: revenue.ie) | construction services usually reduced rate; see Revenue | ||||
| TOTAL incl. VAT | |||||
| Add back: excluded items (normalised) | price anything a tenderer excluded | ||||
| NORMALISED TOTAL incl. VAT | |||||
| Programme (weeks) | |||||
| Earliest start date | |||||
| Retention % | |||||
| Payment terms | |||||
| Validity of tender (days) | |||||
| Qualifications / exclusions | |||||
| Tax clearance verified (Y/N) | |||||
| Insurance certs received (Y/N) | |||||
| References checked (Y/N) | |||||
| PSCS role accepted (Y/N) |
How to use it: keep all figures ex VAT, then apply VAT at the rate(s) that apply to your job (Revenue: VAT on construction services). Make sure every tenderer priced the same PC sums, and write each tenderer's exclusions in the notes column. See the tendering guide.